Thursday, October 6, 2016

Harr v. Freeman: Informal Brief on Appeal

464 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   401 – 464 of 464
Nifong Supporter said...


Anonymous Anonymous said...
Kenhyderal:

"I have confidence in Dr. Harr."

Explain why, after reviewing Abe Froman's posts. When has Sidney Harr ever achieved any of his stated goals?

He has failed to force the NC Barr to restore Mike Nifong's law license.

He failed to keep Crystal Mangum from going to trial

He has failed to prevent Crystal's conviction.

He has failed to get any of the lawsuirs he has filed into court, in spite of his claim to havean extensive comprehension of the law.

And that record of failure is no due to any imaginary conspiracy against sidney harr.


I failed to prevent Mangum from going to trial because I underestimated the depth of corruption in the state's legal system. Likewise for Mangum's conviction. I am hopeful that the federal courts will rectify the injustices by overturning Mangum's conviction and releasing her from custody. I am optimistic about such an outcome.

Nifong Supporter said...


HEY, EVERYBODY... LISTEN UP!!
IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENT!

I just wanted to let you know that I am thankful for all of your commentary contributions to this blog site... even though some of them are wrong, irrational, and nonsensical. But if the comments were all in unison in content, imagine how boring it would all be. So, thank you all for taking the time to share your thoughts.

Also, I wish that you all have a wonderful Thanksgiving and that you are able to share it with close family and friends.

As you were.

Anonymous said...


Sid:

You have 37 days to exonerate and free Mangum.

It has been 147 days since the end of June, 215 days since April 23rd, 254 days since the Ides of March, 1,098 days since Mangum was convicted of murdering Reginald Daye and 3,449 days since Mike Nifong was disbarred. Mangum is scheduled to be released from prison in 3,382 days.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

Anonymous said...

Sidney Harr:

"Clearly, kenhyderal is correct."

Kenhyderal is twice as correct as you are. Two tines zero is still zero,

"I am not screaming for attention,"

Yes tou are.

"I am screaming for justice for Crystal Mangum."

Crystal got justice when she was convicted of murdering Reginald Daye.

"Whether or not you believe it, Lady Justice is around the corner, and hopefully she will be freed and exonerated before the end of the year."

How many New Tears have come and gone since tou first promised Crystal would be exonerated and freed?

Anonymous said...

Sidney Harr:

"I failed to prevent Mangum from going to trial because I underestimated the depth of corruption in the state's legal system."

I predicted you would say something like that in order to duck addressing the issues you raised. Thanks for living down to my expetations.

"Likewise for Mangum's conviction. I am hopeful that the federal courts will rectify the injustices by overturning Mangum's conviction and releasing her from custody. I am optimistic about such an outcome."

Presumes a fact not in evidence, that Mangum's conviction was unjust.

Anonymous said...

Sidney Harr:

"I just wanted to let you know that I am thankful for all of your commentary contributions to this blog site... even though some of them are wrong, irrational, and nonsensical."

The only individuals posting wrong, irrational and nonsensical comments are you and Kenhyuderal.

guiowen said...

I don't understand, Sidney. On the one hand you say that "any politician with political ambitions will most likely side with Duke University, the state, and the media against Crystal Mangum and me." On the other, you say exoneration is a matter of "days, if not weeks."
How can you reconcile those two statements?

Anonymous said...

Sidnry Harr denies he is a fool. If he really believes that "any politician with political ambitions will most likely side with Duke University, the state, and the media against Crystal Mangum and me.", he demonstrates he is not just a fool but a deluded fool.

Cosidering his long history of total abjctfailure, he believes politicians are afraid of him.

Anonymous said...

Sid,

You (Crystal) hasn't filed anything in Federal Court that can exonerate Crystal or result in a new trial (and there would still be a hearing). So why are you lying about her exoneration being close? No hearing is set, and nothing has been filed.

Are you really this stupid or is this all a joke?

A Lawyer said...

Happy Thanksgiving to Dr. Harr and all commenters.

Walt said...

Anon at 5:07 PM wrote: "Crystal got justice when she was convicted of murdering Reginald Daye."

Ding - Ding - Ding! Ladies and Gentlemen, we have a winner!

Walt-in-Durham

Anonymous said...


Sid:

You have 36 days to exonerate and free Mangum.

It has been 148 days since the end of June, 216 days since April 23rd, 255 days since the Ides of March, 1,099 days since Mangum was convicted of murdering Reginald Daye and 3,450 days since Mike Nifong was disbarred. Mangum is scheduled to be released from prison in 3,381 days.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

kenhyderal said...

Anon at 5:07 PM wrote: "Crystal got justice when she was convicted of murdering Reginald Daye.".................... Hah! You call that justice? Only people who, for no rational reason, despise Crystal believe that she is a murderer. I see you got the usual knee-jerk endorsement from Walt, a man who desperately tries to defend the corrupt US Justice System eg. Zimmerman walks; Crystal is found guilty. Why did the Jury get it wrong? That's because like most poor in the US they receive woefully inept council. The Justice and Legal System; just one more area where America is "exceptionally bad"

Anonymous said...

Actually, the American justice system got the Zimmerman and Magnum cases right.

Anonymous said...

Kenny,

Please explain how poor defendants in Canada, unlike those in the US, are assured of having the very best lawyers available? Does the defendant get to choose any lawyer they want and then send the entire bill to the crown irrespective of cost?

kenhyderal said...

They have no such assurance and no such choice. But, hey, lets look at what happens in practice. The incarceration rates per 100,000- Canada 114 and at "number one" The Exceptional USA at 635. The only other country coming close is Turkmenistan at 583. No figures for North Korea but it is estimated at 600-800. Anybody see anything wrong with this picture? Think there might be some victims?

guiowen said...

Kenhyderal,
Is there any way we can get you to stop whining?

Anonymous said...

Kenhydrtal:

"Crystal is found guilty. Why did the Jury get it wrong?

Presumes a fact not in evidence, that the jury got it wrong.

Kenhyderal again shows how ignorant and biased he is, how resentful he is that he is no a US citizen.

kenhyderal said...

@ Guiowen: When the complaints voiced are trivial and inconsequential; that's whining. Think the problems with American Justice fit into those categories?

kenhyderal said...

Anonymous said: "Kenhyderal again shows how ignorant and biased he is, how resentful he is that he is no a US citizen"...................OMG

Anonymous said...

Kenhyderal:

"Anonymous said: "Kenhyderal again shows how ignorant and biased he is, how resentful he is that he is no a US citizen"...................OMG'

Kenhyderal again shows how resentful he is thayt he is not a US citizen, What happened KH? You tried to get into the US and were denied for some reason?

Anonymous said...

Kenhyderal:

"@ Guiowen: When the complaints voiced are trivial and inconsequential; that's whining. Think the problems with American Justice fit into those categories? "

No, that is the problem with Kenhyderal.

However his bigger problem is, he doesn't comprehend the magnitude of his whining.

Anonymous said...

Kenhyderal:

That Crystal Mangum could not railroad the three innocent men she accused of rape, that she could not get a pass for murdering Reginald daye, after she got passes for her previous crimes, that is not a case of of an unfortunate defendant getting mistreated by the US justice system.

Nifong Supporter said...


Anonymous Anonymous said...
Sid,

You (Crystal) hasn't filed anything in Federal Court that can exonerate Crystal or result in a new trial (and there would still be a hearing). So why are you lying about her exoneration being close? No hearing is set, and nothing has been filed.

Are you really this stupid or is this all a joke?



Are you absolutely sure that there's nothing pending in Federal Court that is capable of exonerating Crystal or resulting in a new trial? Try checking carefully and you will find that you are mistaken.

Nifong Supporter said...


Anonymous guiowen said...
I don't understand, Sidney. On the one hand you say that "any politician with political ambitions will most likely side with Duke University, the state, and the media against Crystal Mangum and me." On the other, you say exoneration is a matter of "days, if not weeks."
How can you reconcile those two statements?



gui, mon ami, resolution will come through the courts. The overwhelming truths of the case will be impossible to ignore, and as a Pro Se petitioner, Crystal will prevail. It's only a matter of time before a ruling is issued that will culminate in her freedom.

Anonymous said...


Sidney: Are you absolutely sure that there's nothing pending in Federal Court that is capable of exonerating Crystal or resulting in a new trial? Try checking carefully and you will find that you are mistaken.

Why don't you explain to your readers what you have filed rather than acting like a smug asshole. Transparency would be helpful.

Anonymous said...

Sidney Harr:

"Are you absolutely sure that there's nothing pending in Federal Court that is capable of exonerating Crystal or resulting in a new trial? Try checking carefully and you will find that you are mistaken."

Wrong!


When Anonymous does his research he will find that Sidney Harr is, yet again, is mistaken.

Anonymous said...

Sidnry Harr:

"
gui, mon ami, resolution will come through the courts. The overwhelming truths of the case will be impossible to ignore, and as a Pro Se petitioner, Crystal will prevail. It's only a matter of time before a ruling is issued that will culminate in her freedom."

Presumes a fact not in evidence, that you know the truth.

It has been a matter of quite a bit of time you have been claiming Crystal will be exonerated. She gas not been exonerated.

Will it happen when kilgo reveals the identity of the anonymous lacrose player who, according to Kenhyderal, witnessed Crustal being raped?

Anonymous said...

Sid:

You have 35 days to exonerate and free Mangum.

It has been 149 days since the end of June, 217 days since April 23rd, 256 days since the Ides of March, 1,100 days since Mangum was convicted of murdering Reginald Daye and 3,451 days since Mike Nifong was disbarred. Mangum is scheduled to be released from prison in 3,380 days.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

JSwift said...

Sid:

You have 34 days to exonerate and free Mangum.

It has been 150 days since the end of June, 218 days since April 23rd, 257 days since the Ides of March, 1,101 days since Mangum was convicted of murdering Reginald Daye and 3,452 days since Mike Nifong was disbarred. Mangum is scheduled to be released from prison in 3,379 days.

John D. Smith
New York, NY

Anonymous said...

Sid:

You have 34 days to exonerate and free Mangum.

It has been 150 days since the end of June, 218 days since April 23rd, 257 days since the Ides of March, 1,101 days since Mangum was convicted of murdering Reginald Daye and 3,452 days since Mike Nifong was disbarred. Mangum is scheduled to be released from prison in 3,379 days.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

Anonymous said...

Sid,

Neither your Duke lawsuit nor your Freeman lawsuit can result in any ruling on the Mangum case. The MAR file (which was turned into a Writ), might, if it's ever accepted.

However, as has been explained to you - none of this can happen without a hearing - and none are scheduled by the end of the year.

Kenny, why do you continue to support Sid in his obvious emotional abuse and manipulation of Crystal? Are you in on it as well? If you really are her friend, you'd make sure Sid wasn't so full of lies towards her.

kenhyderal said...

Spare us your unqualified psychoanalysis. Or, if you are qualified, stop the ethical violation of The Goldwater Rule. Dr. Harr is a man of upmost honesty. It's the truth that will set Crystal free. Truth that has been carefully and completely set out by him, on this blog. Not the manipulated evidence, misapplication of case law and the one-sided presentation to a biased Durham jury who never received relevant information which took place in Crystal's trial.

guiowen said...

Whine, whine, whine!

Anonymous said...


Sid:

You have 33 days to exonerate and free Mangum.

It has been 151 days since the end of June, 219 days since April 23rd, 258 days since the Ides of March, 1,102 days since Mangum was convicted of murdering Reginald Daye and 3,453 days since Mike Nifong was disbarred. Mangum is scheduled to be released from prison in 3,378 days.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

Anonymous said...

So, Kenny has chosen the side of abuse and disgrace. Got it.

Walt said...

Kenhyderal wrote: "Harr is a man of upmost honesty."

The word you are seeking is utmost. And, no he is not a man of honesty. Anyone who misuses the legal process to steal a medical practice is not honest. A man who does not pay his taxes is not honest. A man who makes unfounded accusations against Judges and Magistrates is not honest. A man who breaches confidences is not honest.

"It's the truth that will set Crystal free."

The truth is Crystal stabbed the late Daye to death. She admitted that at trial and tried to claim self defense. No one on the jury believed her, nor do I.

"Truth that has been carefully and completely set out by him, on this blog."

Only in your fiction based existence. The fact is Sid has cobbled together a series of conspiracy theories, faulty assumptions, baseless opinions and outright insults on this blog. None of which bear even the remotest relationship to the truth.

"Not the manipulated evidence, misapplication of case law..."

No evidence was manipulated unless it was manipulated by Crystal when she had sole control of the crime scene. No case law was misapplied. That you do not like the law does not mean it was misapplied.

"... and the one-sided presentation to a biased Durham jury who never received relevant information which took place in Crystal's trial."

The jury was not biased, both sides presented their evidence. That Crystal so obviously lied is all on her. There was no relevant information that was not presented to the jury. Conjecture, assumptions and speculations are not evidence. No matter how much you might wish them to be.

Crystal is guilty and hopefully she is taking advantage of this opportunity to turn her life around and make something productive of herself.

Walt-in-Durham

Anonymous said...

Kenhyderal:

"Spare us your unqualified psychoanalysis. Or, if you are qualified, stop the ethical violation of The Goldwater Rule."

Why don't you tell us what qualifies you to pontificate, about whrther or not Crystal was raped(she wasn't), why she was not guilty of murdering Rginald Daye(she was). What degreesdo you have in medicine, law. forensic science? None.

"Dr. Harr is a man of upmost honesty."

A man who, in spite of his protestations to the contrary, that the Lcrosse players were guilty of raping Crystal is anything but a man of utmost honesty.

"It's the truth that will set Crystal free."

In spite of your and Sidney Harr's delusions,it was the truth which convicted Crystal.

"Truth that has been carefully and completely set out by him, on this blog."

No it hasn't Sidney Harr is incapable of recognizing the truth,and less capable of admitting to it.

"Not the manipulated evidence, misapplication of case law and the one-sided presentation to a biased Durham jury who never received relevant information which took place in Crystal's trial."

State your qualifications to make such a statement, your legal education and experience, your medical background and experience.

kenhyderal said...

@ Walt: Thanks for correcting my spoonerism. Confusing and badgering Crystal about crime scene minutiae, then labeling any inconsequential mistakes as lies may be an effective way to get a Jury to disbelieve a witness especially when not countered by Meier's weak and ineffective defence. The improbable story of Daye releasing the half-dead Crystal and her running into the kitchen arming herself and then attacking the retreating, jealous, enraged, grossly intoxicated Daye defies common sense and does not explain the myriad of knives scattered throughout the apartment. Your speculative and far-fetched theory that Crystal made attempts to stage the crime scene after Daye had fled has no basis other than your own Crystal derangement syndrome.

kenhyderal said...

@ Dr. Anonymous: I have no degree in Law or Medicine but I didn't just fall off the "turnip truck" either.

Fake Kenhyderal said...

Aren't spoonerisms verbal?

Anonymous said...

Kenhyderal:

"@ Dr. Anonymous: I have no degree in Law or Medicine but I didn't just fall off the "turnip truck" either."

Thank you for admitting you do not have thr expertise rp understand the murder of Reginald Daye.

Anonymous said...

Kenhyderal:

"@ Walt: Thanks for correcting my spoonerism. Confusing and badgering Crystal about crime scene minutiae, then labeling any inconsequential mistakes as lies may be an effective way to get a Jury to disbelieve a witness especially when not countered by Meier's weak and ineffective defence."

So you admit Crystal was not a credible witnwaa on her own behalf.

"The improbable story of Daye releasing the half-dead Crystal and her running into the kitchen arming herself and then attacking the retreating, jealous, enraged, grossly intoxicated Daye defies common sense and does not explain the myriad of knives scattered throughout the apartment."

If you were manifesting a modicum of understanding the truth rather than trying to buy Crystal a pass for committing murder, you would realize that is not what happened. The photos Sidney posted, the records Sidney posted showed Crystal suffered mo near fatal trauma.

"Your speculative and far-fetched theory that Crystal made attempts to stage the crime scene after Daye had fled has no basis other than your own Crystal derangement syndrome."

No. You are the one indulging in apeculayion based on your own Crystal Sanctificayion syndrome.

guiowen said...

Kenhyderal,
Here is what actually happened:
Reginald Daye was angered by Crystal's strange behavior. He grabbed her by the hair. He soon realized, however, that what he was doing was wrong, and let go of her. He decided it would be wiser to leave her and cool off.
Unfortunately, Crystal, who was by no means "half-dead", did not cool off, and stabbed him. Reggie, understanding that she was much too angry, left and went to his nephew's apartment.
Crystal grabbed knives and threw them around the apartment, either because she was very angry, or because she thought she could get him locked up that way. She was careful to wipe her fingerprints off these knives.
Crystal then tried to tell everyone that Reggie was throwing knives at her. She clearly managed to make you and Sidney accept her story. Unfortunately no one else did.

Anonymous said...

Kenhyderal

obviously believes riding a turnip truck gives him the ability to understand complex legal and medical issues.

guiowen said...

I might have added that, after the 2010 case, Sidney and the J4N gang (whether with or without Kenhyderal, I don't know) assured her that she could get away with things like burning Milton Walker's clothes, threatening him with a knife, etc., because they could persuade the victim to claim it was all his fault. Unfortunately, Reginald Daye died on her. Too bad, Crystal! Too too bad, Reggie!

Anonymous said...

kKenny:

Is there any evidence to support your absurd claim that Mangum was left "half dead" by Mr. Daye? Photographs? Medical records? Or is this just another one of your lies?

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

guiowen said...

Abe,
Of course it's just another one of his lies.

JSwift said...

Kenny claims: I didn't just fall off the "turnip truck" either.

Idiom summary: "If someone has just fallen off the turnip truck, they are uninformed, naive and gullible."
Source: https://www.usingenglish.com/reference/idioms/fall+off+the+turnip+truck.html

Kenny, can someone who purports to believe that Crystal was violently gang raped at the lacrosse party by mystery rapists reasonably claim that they did not "just fall off the turnip truck"?

Your support for that preposterous theory is that (i) Crystal claimed she had been violently gang raped at the lacrosse party and (ii) you can propose a scenario that is consistent with that claim that cannot be disproven with metaphysical certainty. A person who actually believes that ridiculous theory can be seen as "naive and gullible."

John D. Smith
New York, NY

Anonymous said...

Sid:

Are you advising Dylann Roof? Is that why you have not had time to comment recently?

http://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/28/us/dylann-roof-charleston-massacre.html?_r=0

kenhyderal said...

@ Guiowen": Your scenario is wrong on every count. Drunken Daye was angered by irrational jealousy after Crystal exchanged pleasantries with a policeman friend. He interpreted that as disrespecting him. Nothing strange in her behaviour there. Initially he tried to keep her from leaving because of his anger. She locked herself in the bathroom for protection because this enraged maniac was try kill her by hurling knives at her. He heard her trying to call for help and then proceeded to kick down the door. Only then did he drag her out by the hair. He then tried to choke the life out of her. With him on top of her and gasping for air she reached out and grabbed one of the knives scattered about. She immediately grabbed her purse and fled for her life leaving Day behind in his own apartment. Making Daye out to be a victim of a homicidal Crystal is ludicrous.

guiowen said...

Sorry, Kenhyderal, but your story is ridiculous. Daye did get very angry but he was enough of a gentleman to realize that this was not the way to straighten things out with Crystal. He therefore decided to leave and come back after things had cooled down. She however figured it was time to teach him a lesson: she felt she could count on his assuming the blame. After all this had worked with good old Milton. It might have worked here too, except she actually killed poor old Reggie. No way she could get him to assume the blame.

guiowen said...

Kenhyderal,
It's too bad that, back in 2010, you and your friends did not explain to Crystal that she had dodged a bullet, and might not be so lucky the next time.

Anonymous said...


Sid:

You have 32 days to exonerate and free Mangum.

It has been 152 days since the end of June, 220 days since April 23rd, 259 days since the Ides of March, 1,103 days since Mangum was convicted of murdering Reginald Daye and 3,454 days since Mike Nifong was disbarred. Mangum is scheduled to be released from prison in 3,377 days.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

Anonymous said...

Kimhyderal:

"[Reginald Daye] drag[[grd] her out by the hair. He then tried to choke the life out of her."

Again, the photographs posted by Sidney Hatt and the records Sidney Harr showed no evidence that Crystal suffered the trauma you described.

Crystal made no such allegations when she was arrested.According to Sidney she declined to gave any statement when read her Miranda rights.

Anonymous said...

Kenny,

Given that Sid has zero chance of getting Crystal out by the end of the year - because nothing has been filed that could work (and even if it had, there would be a hearing, and none are set), why do you continue to support his lies to Crystal that it's possible?

Unless or until there is a hearing, she's not getting out. Sid's promises that she will be released without a hearing are just cruel - and I don't understand why you, as a supposed friend, support those lies to her.

You can still say he's helping her, and you hope she may get released without supporting his blatant lies that it's close.

Why do you support his abuse of Crystal?

Anonymous said...

Kenhygeral:

Sidney Harr claimed the police read Crystal her Miranda rights because they knew she would claim self defense and that reading her her rights, including her right to remain silent would prevent her from claiming self defense.

Maybe you could explain how advising someone under arrest oh the right to remain silent would prevent the defendant from claiming self defense. That is if you are still riding your turnip truck.

guiowen said...

Kenhyderal tells us that Sidney will soon get Crystal exonerated. This means he (Kenny) doesn't have to do anything about it.
If we ask him why he isn't doing anything, he will insist that he is indeed doing something very important -- he just won't tell us about it as it would reveal his strategy to the evil p.t.b.'s

Anonymous said...


Sid:

You have 31 days to exonerate and free Mangum.

It has been 153 days since the end of June, 221 days since April 23rd, 260 days since the Ides of March, 1,104 days since Mangum was convicted of murdering Reginald Daye and 3,455 days since Mike Nifong was disbarred. Mangum is scheduled to be released from prison in 3,376 days.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

Anonymous said...


Sid:

You have 30 days to exonerate and free Mangum.

It has been 154 days since the end of June, 222 days since April 23rd, 261 days since the Ides of March, 1,105 days since Mangum was convicted of murdering Reginald Daye and 3,456 days since Mike Nifong was disbarred. Mangum is scheduled to be released from prison in 3,375 days.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

Anonymous said...


Sid:

You have 29 days to exonerate and free Mangum.

It has been 155 days since the end of June, 223 days since April 23rd, 262 days since the Ides of March, 1,106 days since Mangum was convicted of murdering Reginald Daye and 3,457 days since Mike Nifong was disbarred. Mangum is scheduled to be released from prison in 3,374 days.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

Anonymous said...


Sid:

You have 28 days to exonerate and free Mangum.

It has been 156 days since the end of June, 224 days since April 23rd, 263 days since the Ides of March, 1,107 days since Mangum was convicted of murdering Reginald Daye and 3,458 days since Mike Nifong was disbarred. Mangum is scheduled to be released from prison in 3,373 days.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

Anonymous said...

Hey Sidney:

When will you next emerge from the hole in which you hide and tell us again how much mothing you are doing?

Nifong Supporter said...


Anonymous guiowen said...
Kenhyderal,
It's too bad that, back in 2010, you and your friends did not explain to Crystal that she had dodged a bullet, and might not be so lucky the next time.


gui, mon ami, you call serving three months on a trifling vandalism incident dodging a bullet? Hardly. Had it been anyone else, she never would have been charged. Since the Duke Lacrosse case Mangum has been targeted by the establishment, state, Powers-That-Be, and the media. What they did in 2010 is make a huge mountain out of a pimple.

«Oldest ‹Older   401 – 464 of 464   Newer› Newest»