Friday, September 16, 2022

Crystal Mangum's recently filed briefs ignored by the media

345 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   201 – 345 of 345
Anonymous said...


Kenny,

You conceded earlier this month that you have no proof and today is the deadline for you to pay the $100. Have you transferred the money to Sid?

Anonymous said...


Kenny,

Why are you hiding?

Anonymous said...


There are 24 days until Thanksgiving.

There are 55 days until Christmas.


Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

Anonymous said...

Hey Sid,

Why are you not releasing comments?

Anonymous said...


There are 23 days until Thanksgiving.

There are 54 days until Christmas.


Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

Jack Burton said...

You know what ol’ Kenhyderal says at a time like this?
“Have ya paid your bet, Kenny? Yessir, the check is in the mail."

Anonymous said...

Kenny is a welcher.

Anonymous said...

dhall,

Have you been contacted by Sid or Kenny?

Anonymous said...


Where is Kenny?

Anonymous said...


Kenny,

Where is the money?

kenhyderal said...

@ Jack Burton 11-1-22 4:38 Right you are Jack.

Anonymous said...

Kenny,

Where is the money?

Anonymous said...


There are 22 days until Thanksgiving.

There are 53 days until Christmas.


Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

dhall said...

Neither Kenhyderal nor Dr. Harr have contacted me regarding this bet or the money.

I honestly don’t expect them to, regardless of Kenhyderal’s affirmation with ol’ Jack “We really shook the pillars of heaven, didn't we, Wang?” Burton.

Kenhyderal could have simply asked for my contact information from Dr. Harr and reached out to me privately (removing Dr. Harr as the “middleman”). Kenhyderal chose not to do so.

Why is that, Kenhyderal?

Prince Humperdinck said...

Sid -- Was there a previous lawsuit filed against Eddie Buffaloe or the NCDPS? I don't recall one, so I don't understand why there's a request for rehearing for it. If there was one, it doesn't look like you ever posted it on this blog.

Is this actually a request for a rehearing of the failed 2016 Habeas petition (initially a misfiled MAR)?



Fake guiowen Supporter said...

@Kenhyderal November 1, 2022 at 8:06 PM A sarcastic man is a wounded man.

kenhyderal supporter said...


Dr. Harr,

It is time for you to enforce the kenhyderal supporter doctrine more strictly. Much like Assistant D.A. Coggins-Franks, a number of the posters are badgering kenhyderal.

Anonymous said...

Sid,

There are 23 days until Thanksgiving.

There are 54 days until Christmas.


Fake Fake Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

Prince Humperdinck said...

NM -- The previous lawsuit was Eric Hooks (now Deputy Administrator of FEMA) and the NCDPS.

Anonymous said...

"There is a particular area in which my attention has been focused for some time and I believe it very likely will result in Mangum's release."


Before I get my hopes up that Crystal will be released this year, do you consider this just "likely" or do you NAMATH-GUARANTEE that she will be released?

I mean "likely" is just a 51% chance that something may happen...

a NAMATH-GUARANTEE, though...we all know those are 100% going to happen.

Fake Abe Froman said...


Is Fake Fake Abe Froman the real Abe Froman?


Fake Abe Froman
Chicago, IL


Nifong Supporter said...


dhall said...
I’ve not heard from either Kenhyderal or Dr. Harr.

Perhaps Kenhyderal is waiting for Dr. Harr to confirm he has the medical records from Crystal Mangum’s ER visit and that these records contain the toxicology reports from that visit.

October 29, 2022 at 11:58 AM


Hey, dhall.

I obtained those medical records about Mangum's visit to Duke Hospital's E.R. in 2006 for the purpose of giving a copy to Justin Glawe which he stated he needed for an article about the truths of Mangum's wrongful conviction to be published in The Daily Beast. As I stated, I felt terribly betrayed when The Daily Beast did not follow through with an objective article about Mangum on the tenth anniversary of the Duke Lacrosse case.

I have not been mulling over Mangum's medical records... I do not know where they are physically or electronically in my thousands of folders. So I cannot weigh in on any toxicology reports.

Nifong Supporter said...


Prince Humperdinck said...
Sid -- Was there a previous lawsuit filed against Eddie Buffaloe or the NCDPS? I don't recall one, so I don't understand why there's a request for rehearing for it. If there was one, it doesn't look like you ever posted it on this blog.

Is this actually a request for a rehearing of the failed 2016 Habeas petition (initially a misfiled MAR)?

November 2, 2022 at 9:01 AM


Hey, Prince Humperdinck.

Lawsuits filed against the NC Department of Public Safety, now led by Eddie Buffaloe who took over for Erik Hooks, were Petitions for Writ of Habeas Corpus. The first writ against NC DPS was under Secretary Hooks and was based on facts of case. The second writ for Habeas Corpus with the NC DPS under Secretary Buffaloe was based on the report of Dr. Cyril Wecht reviewing the autopsy of Dr. Clay Nichols.

The first Habeas petition was denied, as was the second one recently. Currently, Mangum has a motion filed for a rehearing en banc (a review by the entire fifteen member appellate judges of the Fourth Circuit) with regards to the second Habeas petition. Though a ruling to deny the rehearing is likely, one has not been made by the three-judge panel as of today to my knowledge.

Hope this explanation provides some elucidation.

Guiowen said...

So, Sidney,
Do you still think your current plan is going anywhere?

Anonymous said...


Sid,

There are 21 days until Thanksgiving.

There are 52 days until Christmas.


Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

Anonymous said...


Kenny,

Where’s the money?

Anonymous said...


Sid,

There are 20 days until Thanksgiving.

There are 51 days until Christmas.


Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

Nifong Supporter said...


HEY, EVERYBODY... LISTEN UP!
IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENT!

First, Happy Guy Fawkes Day!

Regarding Crystal's case, strategy is in a holding pattern awaiting action by the State. Was hoping to have some movement by the 9th... but it seems as though the State has adopted the Trumpian strategy of delay, delay, delay. If the State would act immediately, and in good faith, Mangum has a good chance of being out by Thanksgiving.

Have a fab day, all.

Nifong Supporter said...


Anonymous Guiowen said...
So, Sidney,
Do you still think your current plan is going anywhere?

November 2, 2022 at 11:08 PM


Hey, gui, mon ami.

In order for my plan to work, it requires the State to act and act in good faith. If the State finally agrees to work objectively and for a fair outcome, Crystal will be free by Thanksgiving.

Anonymous said...


Kenny,

Please explain why you have not paid the $100 you owe after losing your bet. Was Abe Froman correct when he called you a welcher?

guiowen said...

Please do not call Kenny a welcher. It's just that, because of context, he is not yet certain whether one of his posts had the desired proof.

kenhyderal said...

@ Anonymous 11-5-22:-- The $100.00 has been conditonaly paid. It will be up to dHall to donate 200.00 to Justice4Nifong when I present my proof. I contend that dHall has not shown adequate proof but, on the basis of what he has shown, posters here disagree with me. That's why I am satisfied to advance him the $100.00, which I trust will be returned in the form of a donation to J4N at the time my proof is forthcoming. Meanwhile he can notify Dr. Harr as to the charity of his choice.

Anonymous said...


Sid,

There are 19 days until Thanksgiving.

There are 50 days until Christmas.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

A Durham Man said...


Kenny’s welching on the bet has resulted in one positive outcome. In order to avoid further embarrassment, Kenny has stopped posting here.



Guiowen said...

Kenny,
If I understand you correctly, you want your $100 to go to Dhall's favorite charity. If you (somehow) manage to give the proof you need, then Dhall must wind up paying $200. So: if you lose, you pay $100. If you win, Dhall pays $200. CLEVER!

Guiowen said...

Sidney,
So what you're saying seems to be, if the state does what you want, CGM will be out in three weeks.

Anonymous said...


Sid,

There are 18 days until Thanksgiving.

There are 49 days until Christmas.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

dhall said...

Just to clarify-

To date, I have not received anything from Kenhyderal or Dr. Harr.

His statement that the “$100.00 has been conditonaly paid…” is not true.

I will inform you when it is.

Of course, just as in our bet, I demand proof that this alleged $100.00 does in fact, go to a charity.

Dr. Harr, did Kenhyderal get this money to you? What can you do to prove to me that you received it?

dhall said...

I conditionally paid J4N $200.00.





….Just take my word for it.

A Durham Man said...


A Durham Man,

You spoke too soon. kenhyderal has been working with his secret source and he will provide his proof in due course.

kenhyderal supporter said...


Right on A Durham Man.

Anonymous said...


Sid,

There are 17 days until Thanksgiving.

There are 48 days until Christmas.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

Anonymous said...


Sid,

Did you receive $100 from Kenny?

Anonymous said...


Kenny,

Who is your source?

dhall said...

No notification from either Kenhyderal or Dr. Harr. We are now 1 week past the bet deadline.

The bet has NOT been "...conditonaly paid.", regardless of what you see from Kenhyderal.

Kenhyderal, Dr. Harr has my contact information if you would like to show proof that this $100.00 was actually sent to Dr. Harr.

kenhyderal said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
kenhyderal said...

@dhall Relax. It has been forwarded to Dr. Harr. Have you designated the charity that you will use the money to suppor? B.T. W., I still contend you have not shown proof positiuve that no toxicology was performed but what you have proffered was, generally, accept by blog posters here; that is my reason for making the conditional payment without proof. Unlike me, I suspect you are being facetious when you state you have also conditionally paid money to Dr. Harr.

Anonymous said...


Kenny,

Where’s the money?

Anonymous said...


Sid,

There are 16 days until Thanksgiving.

There are 47 days until Christmas.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

Anonymous said...


Kenny,

Is the check in the mail?

Prince Humperdinck said...

Kenny --
Why is Dr. Harr your middle man?

Why can't you contact DHall yourself?

What are you trying to hide?

dhall said...

Kenhyderal -- I will relax when I've seen proof that Dr. Harr has received your money. He has not contacted me.

At that point, I will let Dr. Harr know where that money needs to go.

If you want to know what charity I chose to designate, you can contact me directly.

Anonymous said...


Kenny,

Why won’t you confirm your source?

Anonymous said...


Sid,

There are 15 days until Thanksgiving.

There are 46 days until Christmas.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

Anonymous said...

Relax Kenny, no one who reads this blog believes anything you post here.

kenhyderal said...

@ Anonymous 11-8-22 4:08 My source, for obvious reasons, chooses anonymity but both Former DA Nifong and Lawyers for The Team litigants have the information. It's not in their interest, though, to make that public. It better suited their interest, for a time, to critically concentrate on that check mark, as a deficiiency, which indicatied in the SANE form, that no toxicology was done "by them". When they got the information they quickly dropped the matter. DA Nifong was removed from the case and for the present chooses to have no involvement. Rest assured the information can't stay hidden forever.

Anonymous said...


Kenny,

Where’s the check?

gowen said...

What worries me is that, because of context, Kenny might have forgotten who his source is.

Anonymous said...


Sid,

There are 14 days until Thanksgiving.

There are 45 days until Christmas.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

Anonymous said...


Kenny

Have you communicated with DA Nifong about the toxicology report? If he is unwilling to cooperate with you, ask Sid to speak with him. Why do you think Sid calls himself “Nifong Supporter?”

Anonymous said...

Funny how the lawyers (and your anonymous source) had this information, but not the patient.

You’re lying Kenny.

Just like you lied when you said the money was forwarded to Sid.

Anonymous said...

"My source, for obvious reasons, chooses anonymity but both Former DA Nifong and Lawyers for The Team litigants have the information."
DA Nifong and the lawyers for the the the team defendants (a "litigant" is a person who is involved in a civil legal case) did NOT have this information when the discovery was initially turned over to the defendants' lawyers.
Why? The tests were performed at a later date.
Dhall is correct, and you lost the bet -- unconditionally.

Anonymous said...

Kenny's source is hiding behind anonymity; a place of concealment, for trolls here, who snipe at those fighting for justice.

Prince Humperdinck said...

I was the anonymous poster atNovember 10, 2022 8:52 AM

Wouldn't want anyone to consider me "hiding behind anonymity; a place of concealment, for trolls here, who snipe at those fighting for justice."

Anonymous said...

If kenny's "source" (assuming he exists) has proof that the tests were performed he can release that proof anonymously or thru Sid or kenny. He doesn't have any proof.

Kenny is a clown, a liar and, now, a welcher

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

Anonymous said...


Sid,

There are 13 days until Thanksgiving.

There are 44 days until Christmas.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

kenhyderal said...

@ Abe: Not usual for you to stoop to ad hominen attacks. It's a bad sign. Tell us what you consider a lie. As for your racist perjorative Dr. Harr and will be able to refute that as will eventually dhall.

Anonymous said...


Right on kennyhyderal.

Anonymous said...


Sid,

There are 12 days until Thanksgiving.

There are 43 days until Christmas.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

kenhyderal supporter said...


Dr. Harr,

Please contact D.A. Nifong and ask him to call kenhyderal to discuss the toxicology report. With D.A. Nifong’s help, kenhyderal will will win his bet with dhall.

Anonymous said...


Kenny,

What racist comment are you accusing Abe of making?

dhall said...

I think Abe's statements regarding you being "a liar and, now, a welcher" are accurate until proven otherwise.

You have lied about "conditonaly" paying the $100.00 bet because I have neither received $100.00 or been asked for the charity to donate this money to.

Since the above is true, you have welched (that is, you have failed to honor your obligation incurred through our agreement) on the bet.

Now -- it is debatable that your stating this has happened when it definitely has not makes you a clown.

Given these, Abe's statement is not an ad hominem attack, for the following reasons:

1) The statement is not inherently flawed from a logical perspective
2) The statement is relevant to the discussion, justifiable, and involve no faulty reasoning.

Anonymous said...


Sid,

There are 11 days until Thanksgiving.

There are 42 days until Christmas.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

kenhyderal supporter said...


kenhyderal has concluded that Abe’s countdown is racist.

kenhyderal said...

@ Abe and dhall: When confirmed, can I expect an apology? Not holding my breath.

Anonymous said...

Abe’s racist comment?

He left Kwanzaa off his count down….

Anonymous said...


Sid,

There are 10 days until Thanksgiving.

There are 41 days until Christmas.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

dhall said...

It is now 2 weeks past the end of October, and 9 days since you stated the bet had been “conditionaly paid”.

It has not been paid, “conditionaly” or otherwise. That has not changed since you made that statement. Even if at some point (not holding my breath), you actually pay it, that October 5 statement is still a lie.

I do not apologize for statements that are true.

Prince Humperdinck said...

Kenny -- Sid's been aproving comments, so we know he's reading them. Why hasn't he come to your defense regarding you paying off your bet?

I mean, if you paid the money to Sid, he'd have it by now, right? Surely you sent it electronically from your bank, or through a recognized money transfer business (like Western Union).

Either way, you'd have the confirmation number that proves Sid received your money.

Anonymous said...

Hey Kenny -- Can you post Callm3Chuck's email address?

Anonymous said...


Sid,

There are 9 days until Thanksgiving.

There are 40 days until Christmas.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

Anonymous said...

Kenny,

You have accused Abe of making a racist comment and you refuse to identify the comment. Can Abe expect an apology? We’re not holding our breath.

Nifong Supporter said...


HEY, EVERYBODY... LISTEN UP!!
IMPORTANT INFORMATION!

Apologies for not being more active regarding comments, but I have been extremely active in trying to have Crystal released prior to Thanksgiving. The major project to achieve that end has been given a temporary setback due to what I believe is a delay strategy, despite assurances from the opposition to the contrary. Time will tell. Although prospects for Ms. Mangum's release before Turkey Day seems to have diminished, I still believe it is highly likely that she will be released by Christmas.

Although I believe racism is an integral part of the injustice against Ms. Mangum, and that comments regarding racism are relevant in the discussions about Ms. Mangum's case. However, I balk at comments accusing other commenters of being racists... and therefore have not, after much consideration, allowed them on moderation. I believe that such attacks on other commenters distracts and deviates from the essence of the topic.

Also, with regards to a supposed wager between commenters, I have not given it attention and am not involved. This blog site originates from the conservative South's city of Raleigh... not Las Vegas.

Hope to have major news on Ms. Mangum's case within a week to ten days.

As you were.

Anonymous said...

Kenny’s the one accusing people of making racist statements, and you allowed his comments.

dhall said...

“ Also, with regards to a supposed wager between commenters, I have not given it attention and am not involved. This blog site originates from the conservative South's city of Raleigh... not Las Vegas.”

Kenhyderal- Dr. Harr is distancing himself from our wager. You will have to contact me directly rather than work through him to pay your bet.

If he isn’t responding to you requests for my contact information, let me know.

Anonymous said...

So Kenny,

It sure sounds as though Sid has not received the $100 you claim to have transferred to him. Care to explain?

Nifong Supporter Supporter said...


Dr. Harr,

Given the new policy you announced on 11/16, why have you not deleted the comment kenhyderal posted on 11/11 at 8:32 PM? He accused another poster of being a racist.



Anonymous said...


Sid,

There are 8 days until Thanksgiving.

There are 39 days until Christmas.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

Nifong Supporter said...


IMPORTANT NOTICE

I just received a cashier's check in the amount of $100.00 from kenhyderal, and as soon as I receive confirmation that he wants it paid to dhall, then I will do so.

As you were.

dhall said...

Dr. Harr -- You have my contact information, please reach out to me via email.

kenhyderal said...

@ NSS 11-16-22 5:39 Re-read the post. I did not say Abe was racist. I said he used a racist pejorative that is offensive to Welch people. Perhaps he is unaware of that. Do keep in mind that I have been called a racist scores of times on this blog.

Anonymous said...


Sid,

There are 7 days until Thanksgiving.

There are 38 days until Christmas.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

kenhyderal supporter said...


Dr. Harr,

All of the posters who called kenhyderal a welcher owe him an immediate apology.

Prince Humperdinck said...

"I said he used a racist pejorative that is offensive to Welch people."

Do you mean people that work for the Welch's company (you know, fruit juices and snacks)?

People from Welch, West Virginia?

If you mean the people of Wales (the "Welsh"), while it could be considered a slur, the term is not racist. Just as the term "hillbilly" isn't racist -- it's a slur against people from a geographic location, regardless of their race.

Only 4 of the 10 common dictionaries consider the term "Welch" offensive (and those that do vary on how offensive the term is), but none of those consider the term racist.

Consider yourself elucidated, Canuck.

dhall said...

Dr. Harr informed me yesterday that he had received the check from Kenhyderal and provided a receipt showing the money had been deposited.

As such Kenny has honored his obligation to pay the bet. He should not be considered a [racist perjorative]. ;)

I still question the "conditionaly paid" statement from Nov 5, as it shouldn't take 11 days to deliver mail to Raleigh, North Carolina (home of a major USPS Processing and Distribution Center).

Kenhyderal is welcome to show proof that he did in fact send the check on or before Nov 5th. If he can do so, I will apologize for calling his November 5 comment a lie (I mistakenly referred to it as his "October 5 statement" in an earlier comment).

Finally, Dr. Harr and I have come to an agreement one the donation recipient(s).

Thank you to both Kenhyderal and Dr. Harr.

Anonymous said...


Sid,

There are 6 days until Thanksgiving.

There are 37 days until Christmas.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

Anonymous said...

Prince,

The people of Welch, West Virginia have been victims of racial discrimination for centuries.

Anonymous said...

The people who live in Welch understand that Kenny is a fighter for justice.

Abe Froman Supporter said...


Kenny,

You owe Abe an apology.

kenhyderal said...

Welch, Welsh, Whalen, Wallace, they are all derivations of the Anglo-Saxon name for the Celtic Peoples of Cymru. Rationalize it if you like but welcher is in, reality, an Anglo-Saxon pejorative suggesting those so named are inheritenly dishonest like the people of what they call Wales.

kenhyderal said...

@dhall: Working through a third party, I chose not to ask for expedited mail, adding to the cost of my dispersement. Of course. Guiowen has it wrong when he said "If I understand you correctly, you want your $100 to go to Dhall's favorite charity. If you (somehow) manage to give the proof you need, then Dhall must wind up paying $200. So: if you lose, you pay $100. If you win, Dhall pays $200. CLEVER!" Dhall will only pay $100.00, the other $100.00 will have come from me. I will have given Dhall 100 he will have given that to his charity and I will give my winnings of $100 to J4N. At present he has put up nothing. In either case there is no enrichment of the either. Worthwhile charities will be the monetary beneficiaries, his to his charity and my, inevitable, winnings to J4N. As a winner, my Charity, J4N, will recieve $200. As a loser his will only get $100.00.
November 5, 2022 at 10:16 PM

dhall said...

"At present he has put up nothing"

I don't pay a bet until I lose.

I understand what Kenhyderal is saying --
He has agreed that he lost the bet and paid his $100.00 (through Dr. Harr). His net loss is $100.00, my loss is $0.00
If he does eventually (not going to happen) win this bet, I pay back HIS $100.00, then I pay my $100.00. His net loss is $0, my net loss is $100.00

Apparently (according to Kenhyderal) in the event he does win the bet, his $100.00 and my $100.00 will BOTH go to J4N (J4N is not a charity, BTW).

So...HIS net loss would be $100.00 and MY net loss would be $100.00.

Either way, he loses $100.00. Seems odd to me, but OK.

Prince Humperdinck said...

I noticed you backed off the "racist" aspect of your comment regarding the use of the term "Welch".

Neither the Welsh or Irish are (or were) "Celtic" -- Their respective languages (Welsh, Cornish, Breton, Scots Gaelic) are.

Even then, the Celtic languages and the Germanic lanquages (the languages spoken by those darn Anglo-Saxons) are all branches off the same Indo-European tree.

There is nothing racist about the word "welch". Derogatory? Maybe...Experts (which you are not) can't seem to agree, with the majority of common dictionaries having no indication of the word being so.

Consider yourself elucidated.

Anonymous said...

Kenny,

I hate to break the news to you, but J4N is not a charity.

Anonymous said...



Sid,

There are 5 days until Thanksgiving.

There are 36 days until Christmas.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

kenhyderal said...

@ The Prince: 11-18-22 Racist, derogatory; semantics! But Welsh is closer to Hindi than to English.

kenhyderal said...

@ Anonymous 11-18-22 3:37 Not registered as such but one none-the-less. Charity (noun) Oxford dictionary definition (A2) "an organization for helping people in need"

Anonymous said...


Kenny,

While you are reading the Oxford Dictionary, you should compare the definitions of “racist” and “derogatory.” And also see if you can find a definition for “dispersement.”

Anonymous said...

J4N as an organization does not exist “for helping people in need”. It exists because it was created in support of Mike Nifong.

Prince Humperdinck said...

The Welsh and Hindi speakers have similar accents when they speak English.

Here is the affiliation of the two languages :

Welsh : Indo-European > Celtic > Insular Celtic > Brythonic
Hindi : Indo-European > Indo-Iranian > Indo-Aryan > Central zone > Western Hindi > Hindustani

The only common affiliation? Indo-European. Guess what language also has that common affiliation?

Consider yourself elucidated.

Anonymous said...


Sid,

There are 4 days until Thanksgiving.

There are 35 days until Christmas.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

A Durham Man said...


To paraphrase Lewis Carroll, when Kenny uses a word, it means just what he chooses it to mean—neither more, nor less.

kenhyderal said...

@ The Prince 11-20-22 5:49 : Dahh! Keep in mind though, that Proto-Celtic predates Proto- Germanic by 8 centuries

Anonymous said...

The Welsh language uses the same alphabet as English (The Latin alphabet, the same as English).

Hindi is written in Devanagari script, which has its origin in Brahmi script.

How did you come to the conclusion that “Welsh is closer to Hindi than to English”? Google?

To quote Abraham Lincoln, “Don’t believe everything you read on the internet.”

Try again.

Anonymous said...


Sid,

There are 3 days until Thanksgiving.

There are 34 days until Christmas.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

Anonymous said...


Sid,

Why won’t you release comments?

Prince Humperdinck said...

"Proto-Celtic is generally thought to have been spoken between 1300 and 800 BC"

"..The notion of the Germanic parent language is thus used to encompass both the Pre-Proto-Germanic stage of development preceding the First Germanic Sound Shift (assumed to be contemporary with the Nordic Bronze Age*) and that stage traditionally identified as Proto-Germanic up to the beginning of the Common Era"

*Nordic Bronze Age (1800 – 500 BC)
(all quotes from your favorite source, Wikipedia)

Your "8 centuries" appears to be wrong.

Even if it's not, this "8 century" gap doesn't prove that "Welsh is closer to Hindi than to English", nor does it disprove that English and Welsh have a common affiliation -- Indo-European.

Consider yourself elucidated.

Nifong Supporter said...


Anonymous Anonymous said...

Sid,

Why won’t you release comments?


November 21, 2022 at 9:50 AM


Hey, Anony.

There are several considerations undertaken with approval of comments for publication. One has to do with the commenter. If a name, sobriquet, handle, etc. is used, then the likelihood is much greater than if someone uses "Anonymous." Also, if the comment is redundant... especially if it is silly, then there's the possibility that the comment may not be approved for publication. Comments that are likely not to be approved include those that attack, on a cruel and personal basis, other commenters for malicious purposes. And, of course, comments in violation of the kenhyderal Doctrine are not published.

Unlike Elon Musk's Twitter, I do take moderation seriously and consider it necessary after many years of abuse when I initially did not moderate content.

Anonymous said...


Sid,

There are 2 days until Thanksgiving.

There are 33 days until Christmas.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

kenhyderal said...

@ Dr. Harr Did my reply to Anonymous 11-2-22 4:29 go astray?

kenhyderal said...

Re-post of a lost reply to Anonymous 11-20-22 4:29 : In quoting Presidents, keep in mind "Honest Abe" also said: "I believe it is an established maxim in morals that he who makes an assertion without knowing whether it is true or false, is guilty of falsehood; and the accidental truth of the assertion, does not justify or excuse him." Also don't forget "The Gipper's oxymoron "Trust but Verify".

Anonymous said...

My assertion #1:
The Welsh language uses the same alphabet as English (The Latin alphabet...)

I know this is true.

My assertion #2:
Hindi is written in Devanagari script, which has its origin in Brahmi script.

I know this is true.

How did you come to the conclusion that “Welsh is closer to Hindi than to English”? Google? .

Questions, not assertions.


Do you have any proof that “Welsh is closer to Hindi than to English”? If not, then you have "...[made] an assertion without knowing whether it is true or false, [and are] guilty of falsehood; and the accidental truth of the assertion, does not justify or excuse [you]."


Try again.

guiowen said...

But, Kenny,
Because of context half of hat you say is wrong! How can you verify?

dhall said...

You might find this useful:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indo-European_languages#/media/File:IndoEuropeanLanguageFamilyRelationsChart.jpg

https://www.linguisticsociety.org/sites/default/files/news/ChangEtAlPreprint.pdf

(Thanks, David)

Hindi is an Indo-Aryan language (along with Urdu and Punjabi, among others). As such, it is much (according to the linguistic phylogenetic research documented in the linked article and chart) further removed from the Celtic language than the Germanic or Italic (Latin and the Romance languages).

kenhyderal supporter said...


I’m proud to call kenhyderal my friend.

kenhyderal supporter said...


kenhyderal is a fighter for justice.

Anonymous said...


Sid,

Thanksgiving is tomorrow.

There are 32 days until Christmas.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

kenhyderal said...

@dhall: Thanks for the facinating link to "Language Volume 91"; re: P.I. E. diffusion and it's two schools of thought ie. The Anatolian Hypothesis and the Steppe Hypothesis. These two hypothesis are welll beyond my ability to adudicate. One chart, though, does seem to suggest that Proto-Germanic did diverge ahead of Proto-Celtic, Proto Italic and Proto-Indo-Aryan which would call into question my belief regarding Welsh and Hindi.

dhall said...

Kenhyderal:

If by "call into question", you mean that the chart causes doubts about your belief, I would agree.

You have to go back 3 "divergences" to tie Celtic and Indo-Aryan to the same root language.

You only have to go back 1 "divergence" to tie the Celtic and Germanic languages to the same root language.

Thanks,

Anonymous said...


I have always been facinated by Kenny’s ability to adudicate legal issues.



kenhyderal said...

@ dhall : 11-23-22 1:50 : And it all started with my assertion that the use of the pejorative welcher is a racist slur against. one race of people. the Celtic Brythonic Cymru that was derived from the Anglo-Saxon name given to their homeland, Wales ; itself, already dismissive, meaning foreign territory. That's J4N for you, a blog that's comprised of two irreconcilable proponents; those who believe Crystal was sexually assaulted at the Duke Lacrosse drunken spring-break bash and those who do not. I've personally noted that those who do not feel compelled, in Trump Advisor Roger Stone like fashion, to admit nothing, deny all and attack everything, that is ever proffered by those of us who do, whether related or unrelated, consequential or inconsequential. The suspected motive being to cast doubt, in every respect, on the integrity of Crystal Mangum and those who support her.

kenhyderal supporter said...


Right on kenhyderal.

Prince Humperdinck said...

There are people here who, in Roger Stone fashion, admit nothing, deny all and attack everything,

The problem is that you and Sid always think it’s someone else.

You were proven wrong. Admit it and move on.

Nifong Supporter said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Nifong Supporter said...


HEY, EVERYBODY... LISTEN UP!!
IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENTS!

First, I hope everyone has a wonderful Thanksgiving Holiday with family and close friends... and hopefully with many blessings for which to be thankful. I am thankful for many things this holiday, not the least of which is the participation of commenters to this blog site which gives it relevance.

Unfortunately I was unable to have Crystal Mangum freed by Abe's first deadline of today. That is due to circumstances out of my control... essentially the Trumpian delay strategy adopted by the State's DHHS and Office of the Chief Medical Examiner. If the State eventually acts on the review of Dr. Clay Nichols' April 14, 2011 autopsy report on decedent Reginald Daye within the next few days or weeks, then the likelihood of Mangum's release before Christmas will be greatly increased.

Second, on Saturday, November 26, 2022, I will upload a new feature... an interactive questionnaire in which you, the viewer/commenter, can respond to questions relative to Mangum's case; questions that have been presented to the State some time ago. There will be two requirements for involvement: (1) you must enter a valid e-mail address; and (2) you will have to respond to all twenty "yes/no/unsure" questions. Also, only one submission will be allowed per e-mail address. I implore all viewers/commenters to respond. (NOTE: Dr. Cyril H. Wecht has taken the survey and his responses will be released in a couple of weeks.)

Anyway, have a wonderful Turkey Day and do not ingest to excess.

As you were.

Anonymous said...


Sid,

Today is Thanksgiving. Happy Thanksgiving!

There are 31 days until Christmas.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

kenhyderal said...

@ Anonymous 11-23-22, 3:35 PM : I'm grateful the grammer and spelling police are vigilent, albeit sarcastically. And, for someone without spell-check, I try to do my best. As well, given gnarled and work worn fingers, my typing can be problematic. Hopefully, though, my meaning always comes accross.

Anonymous said...


Sid said:

"Unfortunately I was unable to have Crystal Mangum freed by Abe's first deadline of today."

I did not set the deadline(s); you did.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

kenhyderal supporter said...


I’m proud to call kenhyderal my friend.

Anonymous said...


Kenny,

You should just admit the fact that you lack the writing skills of a middle schooler.

kenhyderal said...

@ Anonymous 11-24-22 3:19 Probably, but not one from the unfortunately, typical, failing, American Middle Schools.

Anonymous said...


Sid,

Thanksgiving was yesterday.

There are 30 days until Christmas.

Abe Froman
Chicago, IL

Anonymous said...


Udaman Kenny.

kenhyderal supporter said...


Dr. Harr,

You need to remind the posters again that the kenhyderal supporter doctrine prohibits mocking and insulting kenhyderal. Although kenhyderal is too proud to admit it, the recent posts by the mischief makers upset him very much.

Anonymous said...

“… all started with my assertion that the use of the pejorative welcher is a racist slur against. one race of people. the Celtic Brythonic Cymru that was derived from the Anglo-Saxon name given to their homeland, Wales”

A ridiculous assertion, as the Celtic people were not a distinct race.

“Celtic” represent a tradition or culture rather than a genetic or racial grouping.

Just like “hillbilly” or “Québécois”..

So, admit your comment was wrong.

Stop denying that your opinions are not always facts.

Stop attacking everyone that points out your failures and inconsistencies.

«Oldest ‹Older   201 – 345 of 345   Newer› Newest»